Coy's Pizza Shop

4.6 ( 645 reviews )
Checking... 08:00 AM - 09:00 PM See Hours
$1–10
2845 PA-56, Homer City, PA 15748, United States
+1 724-479-3831

Coy's Pizza Shop, located in Homer City, PA, is a beloved local gem known for its inviting atmosphere and friendly service. Customers consistently praise the warm hospitality from the staff, making it a perfect pit stop for travelers and locals alike. The establishment is highly recommended for its classic pizza options, with many patrons praising the original pizza as a standout favorite. Brandon Adams, who enjoyed a visit on his bike ride, highlighted the convenience of pairing pizza with drinks and ice cream, establishing Coy's as a versatile "one-stop-shop."

However, while the original pizzas receive rave reviews, opinions vary on specialty offerings—Ashley Smith expressed disappointment with the "paps country sausage pizza," preferring to stick with the tried-and-true classic. In contrast, others like Meliah Brooks and Ruby Shultz rave about the delicious hoagies and Stromboli, revealing the diverse menu's charm.

Khary, a self-proclaimed pizza enthusiast from Philly, appreciated the generous helpings of extra pizza sauce, which enhances the overall experience. For those seeking an authentic and comforting slice of pizza in a friendly setting, Coy's Pizza Shop stands out as a must-visit destination in Homer City.

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Highlights
    • Fast service
    • Great beer selection
    • Serves local specialty
    • Sport
  • Popular for
    • Breakfast
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Offerings
    • Alcohol
    • Beer
    • Coffee
    • Comfort food
    • Quick bite
    • Small plates
  • Dining options
    • Breakfast
    • Lunch
    • Dinner
    • Dessert
    • Seating
  • Amenities
    • Toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
  • Crowd
    • Groups
    • Locals
    • Tourists
  • Planning
    • Accepts reservations
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Children
    • Good for kids
    • High chairs
    • Kids' menu
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Parking

Reviews For Coy's Pizza Shop

Brandon Adams
Jun 22,2025
Very nice place. Friendly employees. We rode out on our bikes to enjoy the nice area and we decided to stop for a drink and bite to eat before continuing. Highly recommend one stop shop. Pizza, beer, and ice cream
Ashley Smith
Jun 21,2025
I love coys' original pizza, but I tried one of the special pizzas, paps country sausage pizza and it was not that good. I now will never buy another specialty pizza here. I'll stick to the original.
Meliah Brooks
Jun 4,2025
Love the pizza! Hoagies are awesome. Tina's amazing.
Ruby Shultz
Jun 3,2025
100% rating on this shop. I grew up near coys on nolo and ate this often. I now live in Greene County and when we travel up to see family we get food on the way up and on the way back. Our favorites are the Stromboli and pep pizza.
khary
May 8,2025
I’m from Philly and I’m a pizza man. Since I moved to Indiana, it was hard to find a pizza shop. I when I go to Johnstown, I alway see this pizza spot. So today , I stop pass there because they had a good rating. It was good and when I ask for extra pizza sauce , they actually put extra pizza sauce on it. Thank you and yall will be seeing me again good job
Gabe C
May 2,2025
I LOVE Coy's Pizza. Every time my family is in the Indiana area, my kids SCREAM "DAD, PULL OVER! IT'S COY'S PIZZA! GET ME SUMMA DAT BUFF CHIC!!" and really, I can't even use the excuse "We have Coy's Pizza at home" because we in fact DO NOT! There's simply nothing like it. Something about that home town feel, the crispy crust, and the ranch sauce (more on the side please) really brings it all together. The family service is amazing! Love seeing a Coy behind the counter! Katie was so kind and gave us take-out boxes so the kids could eat it on the way home to Ohio in the conversion van! A must stop in Indiana!
Clara Chapman
Apr 30,2025
I’ve moved away from the area several years ago, and still talk about this pizza and how great it is. This weekend I came out to visit some friends and family and I was stoked to stop by and get some of this pizza while I was here. It still tastes just as great as when I was last there. The crust is robust and thick! Great for how much they load up the pizza with. There’s always so much cheese and toppings that you NEED to have a hearty dough. But it’s soft all the way to the crust. Perfectly cooked and perfectly adorned with cheese and sauce. I’m sad that I no longer live around here so it might be a while before I can eat another one of their great pizzas. So please. Go there for me. And get one pizza of each perogie, bbq chicken, Buffalo chicken.
Dylan Gorman
Mar 27,2025
Amazing food, and even better service at both locations. (Nolo and Homer City) Their Stromboli which comes in Regular and Deluxe are both amazing. I can’t recommend enough. Great prices also. Lifelong customer.

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta
(475 review)
Jimmy's Pizza & Pasta
  • 31 Kendall Way, Malta, NY 12020, United States
Pizza restaurant
+1 518-899-2939
Burger Nine
(170 review)
Burger Nine
  • Unit 10, The Aylesham Centre, Rye Ln, London SE15 5EW, United Kingdom
hamburger restaurant
Feijoah Cozinha
(177 review)
Feijoah Cozinha
  • Praca Mexico, 216 - Concordia, Belo Horizonte - MG, 31110-610, Brazil
restaurant
+55 31 3568-7154
Jacks N Joe
(1623 review)
Jacks N Joe
  • 2498 S Figueroa St, Los Angeles, CA 90007, United States
Breakfast restaurant
+1 213-748-4565
Indian Spice
(1702 review)
Indian Spice
  • 647 Upper James St, Hamilton, ON L9C 2Y9, Canada
Indian restaurant
+1 289-309-1888
Xolo: Maiz Agave Chile
(525 review)
Xolo: Maiz Agave Chile
  • Malecon, Estacionamiento benito juarez, Local 3, Centro, 48300 Puerto Vallarta, Jal., Mexico
mexican restaurant
+52 33 8526 1722
What A Dish Cafe & Catering
(489 review)
What A Dish Cafe & Catering
  • 24921 Dana Point Harbor Dr b100, Dana Point, CA 92629, United States
Restaurant
+1 949-276-4884
Windmill Family Restaurant
(1683 review)
Windmill Family Restaurant
  • 2838 Main St, Morgantown, PA 19543, United States
family restaurant
Five Guys Baker Street
(956 review)
Five Guys Baker Street
  • 194 Baker St, London NW1 5RT, United Kingdom
Hamburger restaurant
+44 20 7870 8140
Sharma Ji Sweet House and Restaurant
(782 review)
Sharma Ji Sweet House and Restaurant
  • 1043 McPhillips St, Winnipeg, MB R2X 1E9, Canada
North Eastern Indian restaurant
+1 204-417-1100